Utility Icons Redesigning Font Awesome From Scratch
[00:00:00] But highlighter, I just couldn't get it to work, so I dropped that down to just be the tip. Just the tip. Oh, boy. Um, yeah. So that's that. That's the highlighter icon. Yeah. You can get a little chisel- Yeah ... tip there. Well, certainly the highlight of my day. Mine, too
What would you do differently if you got to start over? Not necessarily in life, that's a totally different podcast, but I mean with icons. Say you'd spent years designing one of the biggest icon libraries on the web, and you'd gotten a lot better at it along the way, and if you sat down today with a blank 16 pixel grid and everything you've learned since then, what choices would you make?
Well, that's the question Jory Raphael asked himself, and [00:01:00] the answer became Utility, one of our small batch icon packs for Pro Plus subscribers. And it's designed to be neutral, the kind of icon set that disappears into a dashboard and lets the work get done. But neutral doesn't have to mean boring, and as you'll hear, the personality's hiding in some very small places.
A rounded corner here, a square end cap there, and one highlighter that absolutely refused to cooperate. Welcome to Podcast Awesome, where we chat about icons, design, tech, business, and nerdery with members of the Font Awesome team. I'm your host, Matt Johnson, and today I'm joined by Font Awesome designers Jory Raphael and Noah Jacobus to dig into how Utility got built, the rules that kept it consistent, and the times those rules just had to be broken, as well as a sneak peek at a much bigger version of the pack that is on its [00:02:00] way.
All right, let's get into it. Thanks, Jory and Noah, for coming on Podcast Awesome to talk about our small batch, what we call internally our, our small batch icon, uh, icon packs that folks can get with a Pro Plus subscription. And today, we're gonna be talking about the Utility icon pack. When you're designing something meant to be neutral, how do you keep it from becoming boring, and where do you think the personality is hiding in an icon pack like this?
I mean, I think there's a beauty in simplicity. So that's my answer to that question. Next. I don't know. Uh, good job, Jory. Good job. Uh, I mean, the, the thing with Utility as a pack is, um-
When I had the idea to design it, like, the, the kind of rules I set for myself were that, [00:03:00] um, I wanted to use the existing Font Awesome grid and canvas. So I wanted to keep them exactly the same, the 16 pixel grid, the 20 pixel canvas. Um, and the kind of the design exercise is like, what if we were to design Font Awesome today, knowing everything we know about icon design and, uh, you know, having gotten better at icon design, um, having done it for years and years and years, would there be different choices we might make, um, when building out the set?
Uh, as far as extensibility, as far as the ability to change styles or change weights, I should say. Um, no, I guess I should say styles, but you know what I mean. Styles, weights, tomato, tomato, I guess. Um- Well, you can't weight for style. Oh, sorry, go ahead. Good one. Matt, um, [00:04:00] I don't even know how to respond to that question, first of all.
But second of all- Yeah. Um, so, so not to say that I, I designed Utility to try and be better than Font Awesome, but I was like, if I, if we were to set out to design it today, or I mean, I guess, uh, like two years ago, maybe three years ago at this point- Mm-hmm ... when I, when we started doing it, what choices, what might we make that would be different?
And one of the, the choices I made was to start with a, uh, an outline style with truly using two pixels as the stroke weight. Um, and what F- for Font Awesome, we don't have a two pixel outline style. The, uh, regular is the closest we get, and that's 1.5 pixels, and then we jump up to solid, which is kind of its own, its own animal.
So with Utility, I started there at two pixels for all the strokes in an outline style, and then that, kind of that [00:05:00] decision at the 16 pixel grid forced a simplicity. Like, you just, there is not a ton of room on that canvas size to, like, do a lot. So all of the icons I made, like, had to kind of be stripped to their essentials.
Um, and I think to kind of keep it a little, to keep a little bit of personality there, I had a little bit of fun with mixing the, um, some of the corners and some of the, the end caps. So there's a little bit of a mix of, uh, round and, and square, um, corners and end caps throughout Utility. Um, tried to be kind of consistent with that.
So like inner, inner, inner areas would be, um, sharp with the outer areas being a little bit more rounded. Uh, and it's probably more successful, uh, on some icons than on others. But that was the start of it, was to try and just answer that question, like if we were to, if we were to design it today, what choices w- might we make that would be different than we [00:06:00] originally did?
Mm-hmm.
So when it comes to the sharp corners and the s- and the smooth curves, um, it, it seems kinda like that's an opposite. Like, how did you decide which parts of the icon gets the corner and which gets the curve? Was there a rule to it, or was it each icon you kinda judged on its own, or how did you approach that?
I kind of judged it on its own. I think for the most part, and correct me if I'm wrong, Noah, 'cause I'm, I'm not sure. I mean, maybe, I guess I could look it up, look into the file itself. But I think that the, pretty much all of the end caps on lines are squared off, and then the corners of more rectangular shapes are rounded.
And because it's a two-pixel, um, uh, stroke weight... Is it a, do I have two-pixel corner radius? I think I do. That just by its very nature made the inner corners sharp. Yep. [00:07:00] Yeah, the in- the inherent, uh, rounding on, like, a, a normal centered stroke, two-pixel centered stroke. Yep. So- Gives it that character. Yeah.
Um- Which honestly is interesting because I like those choices you made because it strikes me a l- um, similar to a lot of stylistic choices that are made in various typefaces that have some of that same kind of mix of, of sharp and round elements. And so it kind of lends its, lends a ubiquity, a ubiquitousness to, to Utility in that it can kind of mesh in a lot of ag- more contexts than your straight up Font Awesome Sharp or Font Awesome Classic, which have, which veer more into those, into that rounded versus sharp dichotomy, you know?
And so Utility can kind of blend into the background in a lot more contexts, I feel like. Yeah, I think that was part of it, too, was like, if we, if we have a little bit of a mix of [00:08:00] both, it can, it can kinda straddle the line there. So you can use it for more Um, you know, you could use it for a n- financial website, but you could, it would also be at home on something more fun and playful.
And so, maybe that's what neutral means, I guess, in some sense. That, like, it can live in both worlds equally well. Um, but, you know, w- the other thing that I was thinking when I was designing it was I wanted it to be flexible enough that if we decided to, um, create variants of it in the future, there were some choices that were already made.
So, um, we're working right now, or, or we're pretty close to finishing an update to Utility that, that adds in different, um, styles, so different weights. So, uh, the current one, the two pixel one, is semi-bold, and I've added in a black weight, which is actually two and a half pixels. I've added in a regular weight, which is one and a half, and then a light weight, which is one.
Uh, so we kind of, the [00:09:00] stroke weight goes on in that direction. And then, who knows? Maybe at some point in the future we would do a fully rounded variant or a fully sharp variant. Um, and, and we could build those with pr- th- minimal effort, I think. Um, just c- just the way the system works right now. When I think back to the other icon designers that we worked with on the, uh, the Pro+ um, small batch icon packs, and the different designers we'd talk to, it wasn't real- super structured on, say, like a brief that you were handing to someone.
It was sort of like, "What kind of icon pack would you like to create, and what gets you excited?" So what was the process for the other icon designers, or maybe just for yourselves, but did you approach an icon pack in a, in a similar way? And then how do you kind of craft the guardrails for how you're gonna create it?
'Cause I imagine certain, maybe more hand-drawn icons is a little bit [00:10:00] looser on the rules, whereas something that's more structured, um, seems like it would have to have some guardrails and some rules in place or whatever. How do you guys approach that between icon packs? Well, w- I mean, uh, we've talked about this a little bit in the past, but with the small batch packs in particular, uh, uh, the kind of, the bar f- at least I tried to, um, I had to pass for myself was like, would I get bored building out 300 icons in this style?
Like, would it, uh, you know, either would it get bored or would it kill me? You know? Is this so complex that, like, it would just like, you know, kill me, or would I get bored? And so, I think you gotta first pass that test. Like, do you like this style and want to spend a lot of time with it? 'Cause you're gonna spend a lot of time with it if you once you start down the path, so.
Yeah. Um, so we did that. I mean, we, you know, Noah, Noah did more of this than I did, but, like, taking some time to explore different styles, and I think we had, like, five or six [00:11:00] icons that, you know- Mm-hmm ... we tested out in a bunch of different, you know, all sorts of different crazy things. At angles or at the- Yeah
you know, different weights or corners or whatever, and- An even smaller batch that we kind of used as a test case to see- Yeah ... if stylistic decisions had legs and could kind of be carried on across multiple icons without getting too deep in the weeds, you know, in any one direction. Sure. Yeah. And you also, I mean, as far as rules go, um, I was better at this in the begi- beginning with the small batch packs, but, like, after I had built out a few of them, kind of that initial set, and maybe, um, I think maybe we got up to, like, 25 when we dove into a little bit more, but then built out literally just a rules page where, like, we, you know, uh, would write them down.
So like, this is the rule for the corner. This is the rule for this. Like, you know, if you have a more organic shape, do this. Um, and that could be... Well, some, I think probably some of our packs were a little bit more in-depth than others with that. [00:12:00] Uh, and then- You know, rules are kind of made to be broken, so we would hit, hit th- cases that they didn't, the rules didn't fit.
And annoyingly, sometimes you would come up with a solution, like at the nth icon, that you're like, "Ugh, crap, that's the better way to do this." And you'd have to go back and fix all the previous ones, um- Uh-huh ... to kind of make it match. Or, or, or the flip side is like I'd, you know, recently, like I said, we picked up a new, new version of Utility, and I go in and design a new icon, and I had forgotten some of the rules.
Um, and- Sure ... like, had to kind of look, you know, go back to that document, and then also just, like, hit myself over the head a little bit in reminder for, like, for Utility specifically, like simple, simple, simple, simple. And I just remembered I was drawing, um, we have a new, uh, highlighter icon that I've added to this next version of Utility, [00:13:00] and I kept trying to dr- draw this full highlighter, you know, kind of styled like a pencil or something, and it, it's showing the full shape of the object.
And I just couldn't do it in a way that I was happy with. And I just kept trying it, kept trying it, and, like, inevitably, because, like, the tip of a highlighter, um, you don't have to do it like this. But the way I wanted to do it was have a little chiseled tip at the end of it to, like, you know, like, highlighters are often like that.
And I could not make it look good at the smaller size, like at that artboard. I just couldn't do it, and I kept struggling, struggling, struggling until finally I was like, "Oh, wait, I had that same issue when I was designing the wrench icon," because the wrench icon has a little small little handle that gets smaller, and there's little details with it where the, um, the little C is in it.
And so I was like, "Oh, I just need to make this bigger. I need to forget about doing the full shape and just show the tip of the highlighter." Mm. And so th- in Utility, that's what that icon is.[00:14:00]
I think kind of what I'm hearing, going back to the, the question from before, is that it sounds like every small batch icon set, it's sort of its own thing. You're going to approach it differently. So, like, some, some icon sets you may have kind of strict rules or guardrails on how you're going to build it, but others you kind of figure it out as you go.
I mean, is that generally accurate, do you think? Or do you start with, like, very specific rules? Like, every time I approach an icon set, I have, you know, odd/many amount of rules to give me car- guardrails, or is it looser than that per set? I think it depends on the set. Yeah. Like, it depends on the set.
Because something like Etch that Noah did, like, that is That has some rules. Like, that has some rules that you gotta follow, like, at, at its very core, um- Yep ... that you can't break- Yeah ... or else the style, you know, it just doesn't, wouldn't fit. So- Right ... [00:15:00] um, I think there are probably, probably some style rules, like a top level thing.
I don't know what the name would be for that, but that, like, you just, that is the core of this icon set. That you, like, that, you know, without that rule, it's not this, it doesn't make any sense. Mm-hmm. Um, and then there are little, the little mini ones that you, like, sometimes you break because, you know, you're trying to fit something in a small, on a small canvas.
Maybe what you could do is pull up some of the icons, you know, like the highlighter as an example, or another one, whatever you choose. Maybe you can walk through an icon or two of, um, where there were challenges and what you were trying to do. Sure. And where you, maybe you were getting stuck, and- Yeah
it'd be kind of interesting to have you walk us through that. Air all the dirty laundry. Yeah. No, I do not have a dirty laundry icon. I just don't. Oh, god. Um, so this is actually, this, this page here is an example of some of the [00:16:00] rules that we set for utility, um, when I first designed it. So let me see if I can...
Um, so like, basically, you know, the, the, the core, core, core rules are kind of setting the key shape sizes. Um, in the case of utility, I kind of went a little chunkier than I normally do. So like, this horizontal rectangle is, is a little larger than, um, or a little taller than it might be in, on other sets.
So, um, we set those rules. Uh, you know, make some decisions around stroke weight, around, uh, as something interesting with utility, at least the semi-bold style, is we often have a slightly different, uh, weight for interior elements than we do for exterior elements. Um, just to kind of help with some of the visual density stuff, 'cause when you have two pixel things in a grid like this, it can be a little overwhelming.
Um, and then we also did a similar thing for when we have cutouts in the filled styles so that [00:17:00] you don't get that bloom effect, um, where a, a cutout shape can appear larger than it otherwise would, just because of the way light and dark interact with one another. Um, so yeah, so like this is an example right here where, uh, uh, corners are rounded, interior corners are sharp.
Um, but then you can also add a little bit of... You can break that rule, like in the case of this truck here, where this little, the little lip on the bottom right is, is the little bumper here is sharp, just for some visual interest. Um, end caps are square, but like when you have a corner, it can be rounded, so that little mixy things.
And then, um, uh, this was the original version of Utility. This is what's live on the site today, and you can see we have the single weight or single style, but they're in different families. So we've got the, the standard Utility outline here, then we've got a duotone version, and then we have a filled version.
And so deciding kind of what to do with [00:18:00] the filled state was, was a little tricky in some cases. Uh, like some of them were super easy, like, so like the filled state of this, uh, scissors here, you just literally just fill in the circles and that works perfectly. But then if I were to do that with the pen nib here, you would lose, you would only have the outline shape.
So we kind of had to flip it and see like what are we gonna do if we're gonna do a cutout, um, for that sort of thing. But then, um, this is a little sneak peek, and I'm, uh, that n- well, depending on when this podcast lands, this is the next version of Utility which is coming out. Um, and I have added in, zoom in or zoom out, uh, different, different style weights here, and then added in a new duoline style.
So s- it's similar to duotone except, uh, instead of having a fill, we're kind of breaking apart the different strokes into different, into the secondary layer there. [00:19:00] I noticed when you were zoomed out a moment ago there, um- Yeah ... that there's, there's a heck of, there's a heck of a lot of icons. What, what is the increase?
I'm curious, like what is it going from to now? Just in terms of like, not just like new styles, but just like- Yeah ... number of things represented. You want more? Much more. More? So I think, and correct me if I'm wrong, I don't have it up in front of me, I think currently Utility has 340 40 maybe, 20 or 40-ish icons.
And, um, just, you know, icon, uh, uh, uh, metaphors. And, uh, this new version has closer to 480 I think. Um- Okay. So- Yeah, we're on 338 right now. 338, so yeah. We've added, um, 140 or so more- Woof ... um, to that. And, you know, this was a [00:20:00] lot of them that we were just missing from our core set that we've, you know, add- And then some were just fun ones that I wanted to add.
Um, but let me show you the, uh, the highlighter. Okay, so like our pencils here, like I was talking about, our pencil and paintbrush, you can see these, you see the full thing. Um- Mm-hmm ... but highlighter I just couldn't get it to work, so I dropped that down to just be the tip. Mm-hmm. Just the tip. Oh, boy. Um, yeah.
So that's that. That's the highlighter icon. Yeah. You can get a little chisel tip there. Yeah. Well, certainly the highlight of my day. Mine too. Um, but actually even just looking at this now, having seen that rule sheet again, I realize like, oh, maybe the tip of this should be, uh, should be rounded, that corner.
Um, oh, that's ... I gotta go over to the master component. So [00:21:00] we're, we're, we're doing it live. Here's the other issue. Because, um, this pack has gotten larger, working in this file is a lot slower, um, than it used to be. Yep. You notice that our... Yeah, so I might do a rounded corner like that. Um, our Font Awesome itself, like we have made the decision to break our different categories into their own files just to move quicker in them, but this, uh- Mm-hmm
I did not do that in this. And it is, it is starting to, to show the, uh, start- starting to show that. So it's a little harder to move around now that I have so many different styles in here. Um- But yeah, I don't know. That's Utility. That's the, that's the new version that's coming out soon-ish. And- Nice ... it's big and it's chunky and fun And folks just got a super size for something for nothing, man.
You know? Mm-hmm. You just got a super sized icon pack. Yeah, it's gonna be free. It's free. Nice. Got a [00:22:00] bunch of new table icons. We got some code icons. Is there anything that's new here that is being backfilled into Font Awesome Core that we don't have yet? Uh, no, I don't think so. Um, I actually- Man, I s- I set you up for a great response.
You really let me down. I thought about it. Uh, there are a few- Not quite. Wait, no, actually, that's not true. I think I did do a couple. I actually don't think, I don't think we have this icon, the database plus. I think I added that. Ooh, yeah, I d- I think that's... That is new. Uh, yeah, I think in fact, the ones, yeah.
Having just b- recently been in the devices and hardware category a bunch, that is new. Oh, this is, this is a, a, a fun one. Uh, the armchair. I designed this armchair and I oh, I gotta fix that. I don't like that filled style. Um, I designed this armchair and I was like, "Oh, crap, I c- I can't put it in yet," 'cause we don't have one in Font Awesome.
But, uh, [00:23:00] when I just checked recently, it looks like somebody, a little elf, has added that new armchair icon, so. Oh, we do have a comfy armchair. Yeah, so, uh, that's coming out in Font Awesome. Perhaps it'll make an appearance on, um, an upcoming video series. Oh, exciting. Oh, nice. Exciting. So stay tuned for that, folks.
Um, and then some other fun things that l- just to sh- kind of show what I was doing with this. Like, when I was originally doing this, one, one idea I had, and we ended up not doing anything with it, maybe we will in the future, was, like, could we make a serif version of Utility? So this is a little exploration of that, where I kind of added these little serif tips to it.
Um, which, you know, I don't know how successful that is, but it was an interesting experiment. Um, and then also another, uh, experiment here was, like I said, the fully sharp version at the bottom here, and then a slightly more rounded version of it, [00:24:00] um, as a, as just a kind of a thought exercise that, um, you know, if there's enough people bang down our door, maybe we'll, maybe we'll go that route.
But, um, but I did that kind of as I was building it to see if it, see if it was possible.
Yep. So what kind of project would, um, a designer maybe... Where would Utility be sort of like a front line, first, first pick, uh, for an icon set to consider? Where might it kind of fit personality wise or? I mean, you, Ian, you answer that. Noah, I've been ta- talking a lot. I was gonna say, as an outsider's perspective, only in the sense that I did not design this set, and so, you know, looking at it from, from the outside.
And honestly, it'd be, it might be tough to find a place where it wouldn't work, which is kind of the point. Yeah. With a lot of [00:25:00] its, a lot of the stylistic choices, and a lot of the different UI and type things it could easily kind of mesh with, especially with these new styles and weights. Like, 'cause if you have a much lighter, thinner kind of experience going on, Utility's gonna work with that, too.
Um, I would say, like the thing that comes to my mind first is where Utility would especially shine, though, would be like in a really, like, workhorse UI application kind of sense. Mm-hmm. Like, you know, your productivity software, your dashboards, like all this kind of stuff. Mm-hmm. Where a very simple and straightforward icon set like this will work in like a data and visually dense, rich kind of context.
Mm-hmm. And it won't get in the way, and it will be able to blend into any sort of UI components or, or other stylistic choices you're making. Mm-hmm. Yeah, and another thing that I did with it is like, Font Awesome, we've [00:26:00] always treated our individual styles as kind of, um... Yeah, I don't know what the right word is, but, uh, independent of one another a little bit.
They don't... Like our, our, our solid style is not a one-for-one match, uh, uh, as far as like dimensions even with our regular style. So, um, you know, you can use it for hover states if you want, but we kind of really wanted to focus in on like what is the best way to represent this object in this weight. So, you know, sometimes like with the regular, we had to, you know, remove some detail or, uh, uh, than we would in the solid icon or vice versa.
So with this, I very much had in mind, like I wanted to try and, as I built out the different weights here, to kind of let it be as consistent as I could across each of those so that even though this is not a variable icon set where, where you could scale, like we could probably make one with it, um, at [00:27:00] some point if we wanted to try it between the different weights here because, because they're all, um, all share a lot of the same, same vectors and details and stuff like that.
Yeah, we also, look, I used, we used Figma Motion here, if this will load, to build out some, uh, some fun little previews that you'll see throughout our socials and stuff. Ooh. Nice. At some point. Like and subscribe. Mm-hmm. Smash that, yeah, smash that, uh, notification bell, all the things. Okay. It was hard to name it.
Uh- I'll say, it was hard to name it. I- we went through a bunch of different names for the style. Yeah. Um, I don't remember what any of them are, but I remember it as being a little difficult to come up with it. I remember working through some of those. It always came back around, though, to something, like, stable and useful and- Yeah
you know, something that's not too flashy, but Utility won out. So that's Utility. Two pixel strokes, a [00:28:00] little mix of round and sharp, and a whole lot of simple, simple, simple. And if the update has landed by the time you're hearing this, you're getting roughly 140 new icons, new weights from light all the way up to black, and a brand-new duotone style.
Basically, a super-sized icon pack, no extra charge to you. And head over to fontawesome.com to check it out, and keep an eye on our socials for some of those Figma Motion previews Jory teased. A big thanks to Jory and Noah for hanging out with us today, and for letting us watch a highlighter icon get fixed live on the air, and truly the highlight of my day.
And per usual, Podcast Awesome was produced and edited by this guy right here, Matt Johnson. The Podcast Awesome theme song was composed by Ronnie Martin. The music interstitials were composed by Zach Malm, and we got video editing help from Isaac Chase. [00:29:00] You know the rest. You know what to do. Go make something awesome.